Home > Eye on the Road > Archives > 2008 > February > 28 > Entry
Eminent Domain
The most emotional and controversial aspect of the TTC project is the taking of private land for public use by the government. Those whose property is at risk say no amount of money the government offers is enough because their property isn’t for sale.
But this process, known as eminent domain, is nothing new. All levels of government can take land in the name of the public interest.
Here’s a selection from an article The Daily Sentinel published last year about the issue. The process of eminent domain begins when a federal, state or local jurisdiction determines that private property (or a piece of it) could be useful for construction of a public works project, such as a highway, railroad or water tower. Nacogdoches uses calculations from an independent assessor to offer a fair price for the land. The city is usually receptive to small negotiations, but City Manager Jim Jeffers concedes that property valuation isn’t always simple.
“While there are standards for appraisers to use,” explains Jeffers, “there is also a certain amount of subjectivity, a certain amount of art in determining what the value of a piece of property is.” Because appraisal values assume a willing buyer and a willing seller, the actual value of the property might be different from what the city offers.
If, after all reasonable negotiations, the owner refuses to sell or wants more money than the city is willing to pay, the city can vote to condemn the property, the next step towards the forced acquisition.
Of course, in the TTC example, the state, not the city, would condemn land.
The opinionated and well-researched blog Gideon’s Trumpet has done a remarkable job of discussing some of the case law and historical precedent for eminent domain, which is a murky and outraging concept to many.
To help decipher the law in Texas, the state attorney general publishes a handbook called “Eminent Domain Made Easy” (PDF).
Regardless of legal provisions, it’s obviously from public comments that land owners aren’t giving up without a fight.
Permalink | |
